The Season 8 victor's debut album sold a disappointing 80,000 in its first week, the weakest debut of any "Idol" winner, landing it at No. 11.
In fact, another "Idol" winner, Carrie Underwood, outsold him with sales of her third album, "Play On." The album sold 86,000 copies, pushing it past the half-million mark overall. It was released on November 3.
And Kris' runner-up, Adam Lambert, is poised to make a much bigger splash with his own debut, "For Your Entertainment." The album is reportedly on its way to a 225,000-selling release following the star's controversial performance on last weekend's "American Music Awards."
John Mayer earned the week's No. 1 album with "Battle Studies," which sold 286,000 copies.
Related Content from AccessHollywood.com:
VIEW THE PHOTOS: 'American Idol's' Final 3: Adam Lambert, Kris Allen & Danny Gokey
PLAY IT NOW: Music Video: Kris Allen - 'Live Like We're Dying'
PLAY IT NOW: Kris Allen Living His 'Dream' Of Releasing First Single