Prop 8 Backers Win Right to Appeal

The case will now move back into federal court

The fight over Prop 8, the initiative banning same-sex marriage passed by California voters in 2008, received new life Thursday as the state Supreme Court gave permission for the law's backers to defend it in court.

The court's opinion will give Prop 8 sponsors the rare authority to defend the state's interest.

California public officials declined to appeal Federal District Court Judge Vaughn R. Walker's August 2010 ruling that the law was unconstitutional. That move would have condemned the initiative to die, so sponsors of the law took their fight to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, asking for permission to defend it.

Thursday's opinion gives them that authority.

The case will now return to federal court for the group's appeal.

"While the Department of Justice argued the Proposition 8 proponents do not have standing to pursue this appeal, the court has ruled otherwise," wrote Attorney General Kamala D. Harris in a statement.

"This ruling now shifts the litigation to the federal court of appeals. I firmly believe that Proposition 8 violates the equal protection and due process clauses of the U.S. Constitution and am confident that justice will prevail," wrote Harris.


Get Los Angeles's latest local news on crime, entertainment, weather, schools, COVID, cost of living and more. Here's your go-to source for today's LA news.

California to write new rules for insurance pricing. What's changing for homeowners

False home invasion report leads to deadly Hesperia shooting, sheriff's department says

Although the decision empowers backers of Prop 8, the ruling was celebrated by advocates of same-sex marriage.

"While a disappointing ruling, this case is now back in federal court, where we expect a quick victory. The ruling addresses only a procedural legal question," said Jon W. Davidson, legal director at Lambda Legal.

"We're looking forward to the court dealing with this issue, now, on the merits," attorney David Boies said on a conference call with the American Foundation for Equal Rights.

Read the full ruling here.

More on Prop 8 Ruling:

Prop 8 Court Victory May Be Fleeting

Prop 8 Ruling Highlights Messy Intiaitive Process

Contact Us