Justice Department IG Report: 4 Key Findings on Comey's Probe of Clinton's Emails - NBC Southern California
President Donald Trump

President Donald Trump

The latest news on President Donald Trump's presidency

Justice Department IG Report: 4 Key Findings on Comey's Probe of Clinton's Emails

The Justice Department watchdog's report is unlikely to satisfy either Republicans looking for an anti-Trump deep state or Democrats angry at an FBI they believe torpedoed Clinton's candidacy

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    DOJ Watchdog Report Slams Comey’s Handling of Clinton Email Probe

    The Justice Department’s inspector general released a report on Thursday addressing the FBI’s handling of the investigation into Hillary Clinton’s use of a private email server. It found FBI Director James Comey was “insubordinate” but wasn’t motivated by politics. (Published Thursday, June 14, 2018)

    The Justice Department's watchdog has finally weighed in on the FBI's handling of the Hillary Clinton email investigation and nobody comes out looking good.

    The report paints a deeply unflattering portrait of former FBI Director James Comey and other senior bureau officials. And it is unlikely to satisfy either Republicans looking for an anti-Trump deep state or Democrats angry at an FBI they believe torpedoed Clinton's candidacy.

    Here are a few key takeaways:

    'INSUBORDINATE' COMEY
    The report drags Comey over the coals.

    Footage From 1992 Shows Trump, Epstein at Party

    [NATL] Footage From 1992 Shows Trump, Epstein at Party

    NBC released footage in its archives from 1992 of Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein at a party at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate. The video shows them laughing and pointing as they appear to talk about women at the event, NBC News reported. Trump has said he knew Epstein, but “was not a fan” and they have not spoken in 15 years.

    (Published Wednesday, July 17, 2019)

    It calls him "insubordinate" for not revealing to then-Attorney General Loretta Lynch his plans to make a public announcement revealing that Clinton would not be charged in the case. It says the announcement itself violated protocol and says he "usurped" the authority of the attorney general in making it.

    And it found that Comey "made a serious error in judgment" by notifying Congress, just days before Election Day, that the FBI had discovered additional Clinton emails on the laptop of disgraced congressman Anthony Weiner.

    The report skewers Comey's often-repeated explanation that he was faced with a decision between doors labeled "speak" and "conceal."

    Calling the comparison a "false dichotomy," the report says, "the two doors were actually labeled 'follow policy/practice' and 'depart from policy/practice."

    A 'CLOUD' OF POLITICAL BIAS
    President Donald Trump and his supporters have spent months looking for conclusive evidence of an anti-Trump deep state. In the report, they will find a wealth of politically biased text messages by a handful of FBI employees, including counterintelligence agent Peter Strzok and bureau attorney Lisa Page.

    The report found that the communications, many derogatory of Trump, were "deeply troubling" and "cast a cloud" over the handling of the Clinton email investigation.

    Congress Condemns Trump's 'Go Back' Comments

    [NATL] Congress Condemns Trump's 'Go Back' Comments
    The House of Representatives has passed a resolution that formally condemns President Donald Trump’s so-called racist comments about four Democratic congresswomen of color.
     
    (Published Wednesday, July 17, 2019)

    The inspector general singles out an August 2016 text exchange in which Strzok tells Page "we'll stop" then-candidate Trump from being elected.

    The report says the text is "not only indicative of a biased state of mind but, even more seriously, implies a willingness to take official action to impact the presidential candidate's electoral prospects."

    BUT NO CLEAR SMOKING GUN
    While torching Strzok, Page and other FBI officials for the "appearance" of impropriety created by their texts, the report found that the big decisions in the Clinton case weren't motivated by political bias.

    Of the decision not to charge Clinton, the inspector general "found no evidence that the conclusions by the prosecutors were affected by bias or other improper considerations; rather, we determined that they were based on the prosecutors' assessment of the facts, the law and past department practice."

    Similarly, investigators determined that neither Comey's public statement about the closing of the case nor his notification to Congress was influenced by "an effort to influence the election" or "political preferences" respectively.

    TRUMP-RUSSIA CROSSOVER
    Some of the same agents in the Clinton investigation were also involved in the early months of the FBI's investigation into Russian election interference. And the inspector general singled out one episode of crossover for particular criticism.

    Sparks Fly Between Sen. Warren, Mark Esper Over Ties to Defense Contractor at Confirmation Hearing

    [NATL] Sparks Fly Between Sen. Warren, Mark Esper Over Ties to Defense Contractor at Confirmation Hearing

    During a confirmation hearing for Acting Defense Secretary Mark Esper, Senator Elizabeth Warren said because of his ties to lobbying for defense contractor Raytheon and refusal to recuse himself, he is not fit to be Secretary of Defense.

    (Published Tuesday, July 16, 2019)

    The report faults the FBI for a nearly monthlong delay in obtaining a warrant to search the Weiner laptop. The report doesn't fully answer the question of what caused the delay, saying it couldn't find a "persuasive or consistent" explanation.

    The inspector general did not accept the FBI's explanations, including that some Clinton email team members had been reassigned to the Russia investigation, which "was a higher priority."

    Investigators were particularly skeptical of Strzok, saying they couldn't be confident his personal decision to prioritize the Russia investigation over the Clinton probe "was free from bias" because of the nature of his text messages.

    Still, the inspector general examined the conduct of dozens of other FBI officials involved and found no evidence the search of the laptop was "deliberately placed on the back-burner" to protect Clinton.