Voters Sign Off on State Lawmakers Cutting Peers' Pay

California voters on Tuesday gave state lawmakers the ability to suspend their colleagues' pay along with their voting power when legislators are accused of wrongdoing while in office.

It was the lone, statewide ballot measure in the primary and was proposed by lawmakers who asked voters to give them greater latitude.

Voters agreed, with 77 percent favoring Proposition 50.

Lawmakers sought the change after suspending Democratic Sens. Leland Yee, Ron Calderon and Rod Wright as they faced felony accusations in 2014, when all three faced criminal charges but had not yet been convicted. A state law prohibiting lawmakers' pay from being reduced meant the three Democrats continued receiving paychecks while on suspension.

"We think the voters understood that the Legislature needed and wanted some more tools in the event they ever again needed to deal with the kind of problems they had in 2014," said Jim Mayer, chief executive of California Forward, a nonpartisan think-tank that supported Proposition 50. "This was a very simple choice: If the Legislature was ever going to suspend a legislator again, should they be able to suspend them without pay? The voters said `yes."'

The proposal will permit harsher punishment, but also makes it more difficult to pull off.

The 40-person Senate or 80-person Assembly currently can suspend a member with pay with a simple majority of votes. Proposition 50 raises the voting threshold to two-thirds to suspend a member without pay.

David A. Carrillo, executive director of UC Berkeley Law's California Constitution Center, said increasing the number of lawmakers that must agree to the suspension would be "making it harder for the Legislature to apply this kind of self-discipline."

"Proposition 50 is actually a reduction of the Legislature's existing power to discipline its ranks," Carrillo said in an email.

Only one senator voted against the 2014 suspensions.

Sen. Joel Anderson, R-Alpine, said he opposed the suspensions because empty seats in the statehouse result in taxation without representation.

He argued Proposition 50 is an ineffective political maneuver that cannot correct lawmakers' rare criminal behavior.

"This is another slick, hide-the-pea maneuver," Anderson said.

Contact Us