Nation Pauses to Reflect 13 Years After 9/11 Attacks

Thirteen years is not one of those signature milestone moments, but the families of those lost on 9/11 don’t think in terms of milestones. David Ushery reports from lower Manhattan.

With the solemn toll of a bell and a moment of silence, the nation paused Thursday to mark the 13th anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks at the hallowed site just hours after President Obama promised to root out and destroy a new group of terrorists threatening the U.S.

Family and friends read the names of the nearly 3,000 people killed in New York, at the Pentagon and near Shanksville, Pennsylvania. Thelma Stuart, whose husband, Walwyn Wellington Stuart Jr., 28, was a Port Authority Police Department officer, said the nation should pray for its leaders, "that God will grant them wisdom, knowledge and understanding on directing them on moving forward."

The twin towers, shown in all their beauty, before 2001. This is how we want to remember the World Trade Center.

In an address Wednesday, President Obama said he would open a new military front in the Middle East — authorizing airstrikes inside Syria along with expanded strikes in Iraq as part of "a steady, relentless effort" to root out Islamic State extremists.

The shadow of a renewed threat hung over the ceremony, where the sad roll call paused six times: to mark the times when the first plane struck the World Trade Center, when the second plane struck, when the first tower fell and when the second tower fell.

Adriana Fiori, reading her father Paul's name, wept. "You put me to bed 13 years ago not knowing it would be your last time," she said. "I miss you so much, Daddy."

Joanne Barbara, whose husband of 30 years, Gerard Barbara, was a FDNY captain who died, urged all to feel for not only the lost but "those who continue to suffer from the aftermath.

"May God bless America, and may we never, never forget," she said.

Little about the annual ceremony at ground zero has changed. But so much around it has.

RaischStudios
Steel from the original Trade Center seen in front of the Tribute in Light #September11 #TributeInLight #NBC4NY
LunchTimeViews
LorumIpsum via Twitter
The view from Battery Park City
javanng via Twitter
View of Freedom Tower & #TributeInLight during twilight #911anniversary #nyc #NBC4NY #NeverForget #Honor911
thekevinstewart via Instagram
#WTC #TributeInLights on 9.11.14 as seen from #JerseyCity
primo_no_chillington via Instagram
#nyc #promenade #night #newyork #911 #brooklyn #citylights #memorial
primo_no_chillington via Instagram
#nyc #promenade #night #newyork #911 #brooklyn #citylights #memorial
@nateadamsphotography/Instagram
A stunning shot of the Statue of Liberty and the 9/11 Tribute in Light, taken in 2013. (Credit: @nateadamsphotography/Instagram)
@jeffreynyc/Instagram
A beautiful photo of the 9/11 Tribute in Light as seen from City Hall; posted on Sept. 8. (Credit: @jeffreynyc/Instagram)
@gothamcitymadman/Instagram
The beautiful 9/11 Tribute in Light as seen from across the river; posted on Sept. 9. (Credit: @gothamcitymadman/Instagram)
@jlgross/Instagram
The amazing 9/11 Tribute in Light as seen from Jersey City; posted on Sept. 8. (Credit: @jlgross/Instagram)
@gothamcitymadman/Instagram
The beautiful 9/11 Tribute in Light as seen from railroad tracks; posted on Sept. 9. (Credit: @gothamcitymadman/Instagram)
@gothamcitymadman/Instagram
The beautiful 9/11 Tribute in Light; posted on Sept. 9. (Credit: @gothamcitymadman/Instagram)
@jackb_nyc/Instagram
It's that month of year, to honor 9/11 with the beautiful Tribute in Light; posted on Sept. 5. (Credit: @jackb_nyc/Instagram)
@jackb_nyc/Instagram
"I live 2 blocks from Ground Zero. I witnessed 9/11 up close with my own eyes. There is not enough space in this caption box to describe it." -@jackb_nyc/Instagram; posted on Sept. 8.
@javan/Instagram
The Tribute in Light replaced the fall Twin Towers with two beams of light shooting into the night sky to commemorate the victims of the 9/11 attacks; posted on Sept. 4.(Credit: @javan/Instagram)
@javanng/Twitter
Javan NG captured this unique shot of the Tribute in Light up close. Credit: @javanng/Twitter
@jenperci/Instagram
A moving view of the 9/11 Tribute in Light from Brooklyn; posted on Sept. 6. (Credit: @jenperci/Instagram)
@katiadienne/Instagram
Testing of the 9/11 Tribute in Light; posted on Sept. 5. (Credit: @katiadienne/Instagram)
@ksk_photography/Instagram
Titans of New York; posted on Sept. 9. (Credit: @ksk_photography/Instagram)
@ksk_photography/Instagram
The Tribute in Light pierces the night; posted on Sept. 6. (Credit: @ksk_photography/Instagram)
@ksk_photography/Instagram
An insipring photo of the 9/11 Tribute in Light; posted on Sept. 5. (Credit: @ksk_photography/Instagram)
@lalo_718/Instagram
Testing for the 9/11 Tribute in Light, as seen from a NYC cab; posted on Sept. 5. (Credit: @lalo_718/Instagram)
@nyc_sights/Instagram
A breathtaking photo of the 9/11 Tribute in Light; posted on Sept. 6. (Credit: @nyc_sights/Instagram)
@nyc_sights/Instagram
There is something about seeing the tribute with your own eyes that pictures cannot achieve; posted on Sept. 7. (Credit: @nyc_sights/Instagram)
@rutgersalum/Instagram
The 9/11 Tribute in Light behind the Brooklyn Bridge; posted on Sept. 5. (Credit: @rutgersalum/Instagram)
@robertstevens/Instagram
A test run of the striking 9/11 Tribute in Light; posted on Sept. 4. (Credit: @robertstevens/Instagram)
@rutgersalum/Instagram
"Not a week goes by where I do not reflect upon what happened 13 years ago. They may have filled the open space with new buildings but nothing could ever fill the void left that day." -@rutgersalum/Instagram; posted on Sept. 5.
@stevezaff/Instagram
A beautiful close-up of the 9/11 Tribute in Light testing; posted on Sept. 8. (Credit: @stevezaff/Instagram)
@zeppflyhigh/Instagram
An incredible photo of the 9/11 Tribute in Light; posted on Sept. 5. (Credit: @zeppflyhigh/Instagram)
Eric Sternberg
This was taken by Eric Sternberg on Sept. 10 from Jersey City looking back at One World Trade Center.
Annmarie Corbitt
The Denville, New Jersey, Volunteer Fire Department. Credit: Annmarie Corbitt
Claire Burchill
In a taxi the night before Sept .11. Credit: Claire Burchill
@Iflyaa001/Twitter
The Tribute in Light as seen from the 40th floor in Long Island City. Credit: @Iflyaa001/Twitter
@javanng/Twitter
The Tribute in Light as seen from West Thames Park. Credit: @javanng/Twitter
@javanng/Twitter
The Tribute in Light as seen from North Cove Marina. Credit: @javanng/Twitter
John Gallagher
John Gallagher shot this photo of the Tribute in Light from his living room.
Michael Belling
Taken from Brooklyn Bridge Park on Sept. 11, 2012, by Michael Belling of Lindenhurst, New York.
Michael Belling
This was taken at the base of the lights (end of Greenwich Street) on Sept. 11, 2012, by Michael Belling of Lindenhurst, New York.
@chelleshannan/Twitter
As seen from Jersey City. Credit: @chelleshannan/Twitter
NormaJean
Credit: NormaJean
Tara Whiston
This photo was taken in Union Square on Sept. 5, 2014. Credit: Tara Whiston
@throughopenlens/Instagram
The Tribute in Light as seen from Jersey City. Credit: @throughopenlens/Instagram
Anny Roman
Taken from Pier A in Hoboken. Credit: Anny Roman
@CTIGUK/Twitter
This photo was taken from Hunter's Point in Long Island City on Sept. 10, 2014. Credit: @CTIGUK/Twitter
Doug Salvatoriello
The Tribute in Light in 2006. Credit: Doug Salvatoriello
Credit: @javanng/Twitter
A view of the Tribute in Light from Rector Street. Credit: @javanng/Twitter
Sergio Cardona
Credit: Sergio Cardona
@street25photo/Twitter
Credit: @street25photo/Twitter
Mark Lacari
Mark Lacari took this photo on Sept. 11, 2014, from Staten Island at the St. George Ferry Terminal.
Neil Cunningham
Neil Cunningham took this picture on Sept. 11, 2014, when he was taking out the garbage at about 1:20 a.m. The moon was passing through the Tribute in Light.

For the first time, the National Sept. 11 Memorial Museum — which includes gut-wrenching artifacts and graphic photos of the attacks — will be open on the anniversary. Fences around the memorial plaza have come down, integrating the sacred site more fully with the streets of Manhattan while completely opening it up to the public and camera-wielding tourists.

A new mayor is in office, Bill de Blasio, one far less linked to the attacks and their aftermath than his immediate predecessors. And finally, a nearly completed One World Trade Center has risen 1,776 feet above ground zero and will be filled with office workers.

Jin Lee
These steel tridents in the museum's entry pavilion once formed part of the exterior structural support of the east facade of the north tower. Welded to box columns at bedrock, 70 feet below street level, these branched from one column into three prongs at the fifth story.
Getty Images
A view of the tridents from the atrium entrance.
Jin Lee
This piece of steel, once part of the facade of the north tower, was located at the point of impact where hijacked Flight 11 pierced the building from floors 93 through 99. A companion piece of facade steel from floors 93 through 96 is also displayed in the museum.
Jin Lee
The other piece of impact steel.
Jin Lee
Part of one of the hijacked jetliners
Jin Lee
An animation shows the paths taken by the hijacked planes
Jin Lee
Assigned to aid in the evacuation of civilians in the north tower on 9/11, members of FDNY Ladder Company 3 are known to have reached the 35th floor by 9:21 a.m. All 11 responding members of Ladder Company 3 were killed when the north tower collapsed at 10:28 a.m.
Jin Lee
The Vesey Street stairs, or Survivors’ Stairs, once connected the northern edge of the World Trade Center Plaza to the Vesey Street sidewalk below. On Sept. 11, the stairs and an adjacent escalator provided an unobstructed exit for hundreds seeking to escape.
Jin Lee
FDNY Engine Company 21 was dispatched to the World Trade Center after hijacked Flight 175 struck the south tower. The company’s truck was parked on Vesey Street under a pedestrian overpass, with the cab exposed. The front of the vehicle was damaged by flaming debris.
Larry Wagner/AP
Behind this wall is the repository where unidentified victims' remains are being stored. The letters of the quotation from Virgil’s “Aeneid” were forged out of remnant World Trade Center steel by New Mexico blacksmith Tom Joyce.
Getty Images
Families of people who died visit the museum's hall of victim photos.
Jin Lee
This object known as a "composite" is a mass of building elements, including steel rebar, floor decking, pulverized drywall, carpeting, furniture and bits of paper, fused by heat and pressure into a compact piece. There are three known composites, this includes elements of approximately five floors from one building.
Jin Lee
When hijacked Flight 11 struck the north tower, it severed elevator cables and trapped hundreds of people above floor 93. Below the impact zone, most on floors lower than 92 were able to evacuate down the stairs.
Jin Lee
Part of the World Trade Center’s original foundation, this wall was built to keep the Hudson River from flooding the site by creating a bathtub-like enclosure of reinforced cement. At the time of the slurry wall’s construction, the engineering employed to create it was considered an innovative method for building sturdy reinforced concrete walls at sites close to water.
Jin Lee
Visitors can sign a message on touch screens below this piece of bent steel from the south tower, and the words will appear just below the slurry wall in a lighted display.
Jin Lee
Dust, ash and debris from the collapsed twin towers filled the interior of Chelsea Jeans, a retail store on Broadway near Fulton Street. Store owner David Cohen resolved to capture the moment in time by maintaining part of the store as it appeared after 9/11.
Jin Lee
A bicycle rack located on Vesey Street at the northern edge of the complex was shielded from the impact of cascading debris by 5 World Trade Center. In the aftermath of 9/11, only one owner stepped forward to claim his bicycle, still locked to the rack. The status of other owners and riders is unknown.
Jin Lee
This 19.8-foot fragment was about 1/20th of the 360-foot transmission tower atop the north tower. Six broadcast engineers affiliated with five television stations were working from offices on floors 104 and 110 of tower on 9/11. None of the engineers survived. Transmissions for most stations failed shortly after hijacked Flight 11 hit the building. All transmissions ceased by 10:28 a.m., when the tower collapsed.
Jin Lee
A box column at bedrock, 70 feet below street level, was once welded to the steel tridents to form structural support.
Jin Lee
Operating engineers used grappler claws to lift tangled steel and debris from the pile at ground zero. Spotters worked alongside them, scrutinizing each load for human remains during the cleanup that lasted months.
Jin Lee/Museum
Video of the debris cleanup is projected onto a steel trident.
Jin Lee
Jin Lee
The original model for the twin towers by Minoru Yamasaki
AFP/Getty Images
President Barack Obama and his wife, Michelle Obama, tour the museum with former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and former Mayor Bloomberg. Obama and Bloomberg spoke at Thursday's dedication ceremony.
AFP/Getty Images
Obama speaks at the dedication ceremony in the museum's Foundation Hall.
AFP/Getty Images
Obama and Bloomberg view Ladder Company 3's truck in the museum. All 11 responding members of Ladder 3 were killed when the north tower collapsed at 10:28 a.m.
AP
People gather on the plaza of the memorial to watch the telecast of the dedication ceremony taking place in the museum below ground.
Slawomir Chrzaszcz, Vertigophoto.us
A view of the dedication ceremony in Foundation Hall.

But painful memories linger. Franklin Murray wore a shirt with a photo of his brother, Harry Glen, who worked at Cantor Fitzgerald, one of the companies that lost the most workers.

He said he wanted to see the memorial for the first time, and it gave him a "funny feeling" to know there was now a memorial. He has come to the ceremony before but "before it was getting harder, so I forced myself to get down here."

"Coming down to the area is rough," he said.

See a montage of some of the most emotional elements of the 9/11 ceremony as the nation paused to reflect 13 years after the attacks.

For some, the increasing feel of a return to normalcy in the area threatens to obscure the tragedy that took place there and interfere with their grief.

"Instead of a quiet place of reflection, it's where kids are running around," said Nancy Nee, whose firefighter brother, George Cain, was killed in the attacks. "Some people forget this is a cemetery. I would never go to the Holocaust museum and take a selfie."

Chelsea Narvaez
Photos taken on Sept. 11, 2014, from the ceremony commemorating the 13th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks. This is One World Trade Center against grey skies. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A mural near ground zero. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A mural near ground zero. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A flag hangs from a crane near the Freedom Tower. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Construction continues at ground zero. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
The Freedom Tower is partially obscured by clouds. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
The ceremony takes place at the foot of the Freedom Tower. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A sign directs visitors to the memorial. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A sign outlines rules of conduct for visitors. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Visitors at the memorial before the ceremony began. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Preparations for the ceremony. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A bagpipe player. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
People look at the memorial pools. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A flag is unfurled for the ceremony. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Names of the victims are read. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
The crowd at ground zero. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Police officers among the crowd. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A wreath honoring the victims. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Some in the crowd brought purple balloons. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Lining up to watch the ceremony. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A sign honoring one of the victims. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Taps is played at the end of the ceremony. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A soldier holds a photo of a victim. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Two men hold a "flag of heroes." Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A T-shirt shows the Twin Towers. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Visitors wore T-shirts honoring the victims. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Clothing honors the 9/11 victims. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Attendees wearing FDNY T-shirts. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A blue ribbon honoring the victims. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Sticker for the memorial. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
A man carries a flag away from the memorial site. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Construction around ground zero. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
Flags surround a podium. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez
Chelsea Narvaez
The memorial grounds. Credit: Chelsea Narvaez

But for others, the changes are an important part of the healing process.

"When I first saw (One World Trade Center), it really made my heart sing," said Debra Burlingame, whose brother Charles Burlingame was piloting the plane before it crashed into the Pentagon. "It does every time I see it because it's so symbolic of what the country went through."

"I want to see it bustling," she said. "I want to see more housing down there; I want to see it alive and bursting with businesses."

NBC 4 New York
The new World Trade Center rises through the fog as the nation pauses to reflect on the lives lost in the 9/11 terror attacks.

The memorial plaza will be closed to the public for most of the day and available only to family members. It will reopen at 6 p.m., at which point thousands of New Yorkers are expected to mark the anniversary at the twin reflecting pools where the towers once stood.

The first ceremony at the site was held six months later and was organized by then-Mayor Bloomberg and his aides. Bloomberg, who took office just three months after the attacks, remained in charge, acting as the master of ceremonies for the next decade. He attended on Thursday, along with Rudy Giuliani who was mayor during the attacks, New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie and Gov. Cuomo.  

instagram.com/p/szinddwwWJ/
instagram.com/p/szhs86j3K3/
instagram.com/p/szkqocwwY_/
Copyright AP - Associated Press
Exit mobile version