It all started when city council members discussed putting a dog park off of Camino Capistrano.
Before they could even take a vote, San Juan Capistrano Councilman Derek Reeve spoke up.
"I have two new dogs and I'm excited about a dog park," said Reeve at a recent council meeting. "America and Muhammad want to play with dogs -- that's right, I named my dog Muhammad, more on that later."
Local news from across Southern California
Ray Qoed was in the audience that night, hoping to get approval for a new convenience store. As a Muslim, he said, he was offended.
"I got shocked to be honest with you," said Qoed. "That's his, one opinion, and I don't think nobody agreed with him."
Since that initial meeting, other council members have gone on record criticizing Reeve.
Conservative commentator, Bill O'Reilly, even took a shot at the councilman on his "Pinheads & Patriots" segment.
"Reeve says he named his dog Muhammad to teach his kid about free speech," said O'Reilly on Fox News on Sept. 22. "You want to teach your children about intolerance, there are plenty of other ways to do it."
On his Facebook page, Councilman Reeve joked about being called a pinhead by O'Reilly.
But the Council on Islamic Relations wants an apology, accusing Reeve of disrespecting the Muslim prophet. So far, Reeve has refused.
Resident Jurgen Schambach thinks there is a free speech discussion in all of this. He named his German shepherd "Blitz."
"I don't name my dog Jesus because it's my own choice, but if somebody would like to do that, why not? We should not go to war over that one," said Schambach.