Court: Neighbors Can Sue Pot Grower for Stinky Smells - NBC Southern California
In the Weeds

In the Weeds

Marijuana in the Golden State and beyond

Court: Neighbors Can Sue Pot Grower for Stinky Smells

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Court: Neighbors Can Sue Pot Grower for Stinky Smells
    Getty Images
    Cannabis plants grow in the greenhouse at Vireo Health's medical marijuana cultivation facility, August 19, 2016 in Johnstown, New York.

    A pot farm's neighbor can sue them for smells and other nuisances that could harm their property values, a federal appeals court ruled this week.

    The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruling revives a lawsuit between a Colorado horse farm and a neighboring marijuana-growing warehouse. The horse farm's owners, the Reillys, sued in 2015, claiming that the pot-growing warehouse would diminish their land's value by emitting "noxious odors" and attracting unsavory visitors.

    A federal district court dismissed the Reillys' claim, and the pot warehouse opened in 2016. The horse farm owners appealed, and a three-judge appeals panel agreed Wednesday that their claims should be heard. But the judges said the Reillys can't sue Colorado to force the state to enforce federal drug law and not allow the pot warehouse in the first place.

    The southern Colorado horse-vs-pot case is interesting because the horse farm owners are trying to use a 1970 federal law crafted to fight organized crime. The Reillys say that federal racketeering laws entitle them to collect damages from the pot farm, even though the pot farm is legal under state law.

    "The landowners have plausibly alleged at least one (racketeering) claim," the judges wrote.

    Pot opponents say the racketeering strategy gives them a possible tool to break an industry they oppose. It could give private citizens who oppose pot legalization a way to sue the industry out of business, even as federal officials have so far declined to shut down most pot businesses operating in violation of federal drug law.

    "This is a tremendous victory for opponents of the marijuana industry," said Brian Barnes, a Washington-based lawyer who represents the Reillys on behalf of the anti-crime nonprofit group Safe Streets Alliance.

    Owners of the pot warehouse, owned by a company called Alternative Holistic Healing, did not immediately return a call for comment Wednesday. An attorney representing them in the case could not be reached, either. The case now goes to back to a federal district court that had earlier dismissed it. The appeals panel handed pot opponents a defeat on another case Wednesday, however.

    The judges ruled that a lower court was right to dismiss a claim from a group of sheriffs in Colorado, Nebraska and Oklahoma, who had asked the federal court to block Colorado's pot law. ___ Kristen Wyatt can be reached at http://www.teitter.com/APkristenwyatt

    Get the latest from NBC4 anywhere, anytime

    • Download the App

      Available for IOS and Android