Judge Deals Blow to LAUSD Student COVID Vaccination Mandate

A judge ruled in favor of a father who challenged the LAUSD over their coronavirus vaccine mandate

A Worcester student getting vaccinated at a school clinic on Monday, Nov. 8, 2021.
NBC10 Boston

Finding that the Board of Education's authority is "great, but not unlimited,'' a judge on Wednesday ruled in favor of the father of a 12-year-old student who challenged the Los Angeles Unified School District's student coronavirus vaccine mandate, finding that the resolution approving the directive clashes with state law.

Three months after hearing arguments and taking the case under submission, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Mitchell Beckloff reversed his tentative ruling in which he said he was initially inclined to find in favor of the LAUSD in the case brought by the father, who is identified in court papers only as G.F. and his son as D.F.

G.F. filed the case last Oct. 8 on behalf of himself and his son, a Science Academy STEM Magnet school student. G.F. maintained that the state and not the LAUSD is authorized to issue vaccination mandates and that the district's requirement that unvaccinated pupils 12 years old and over attend independent learning classes outside campus violates the state Education Code.

The judge noted in his ruling that if D.F. remains unvaccinated, he will be forced to leave the academy and be subjected to a different curriculum. Beckloff further said that while the Board of Education's authority is "great,'' it is not unlimited. He found that the student vaccine resolution approved Sept. 9 conflicts with state law and clashes with the state Health and Safety Code by not allowing exemptions for personal beliefs.

"While LAUSD argues the court's ruling should apply to D.F. only, the court finds no justification for such a limitation given the board's lack of authority to adopt the resolution,'' Beckloff wrote.

A spokesperson for the LAUSD released the following statement to City
News Service:

"In April of this year, the Los Angeles Unified School District aligned with the state's timeline for implementation of the governor's student vaccine mandate wherein any vaccine requirement would not take effect until after full FDA approval and no sooner than July 1, 2023. Accordingly, the district's alignment with the governor's student vaccine mandate has allowed Los Angeles Unified students to enroll and attend in-person instruction. Los Angeles Unified will continue to take measures to ensure the health and safety of its students, employees and school community.''


Get Los Angeles's latest local news on crime, entertainment, weather, schools, COVID, cost of living and more. Here's your go-to source for today's LA news.

Mayor orders flags lowered to half-staff in honor of LAFD recruit killed at scene of 101 Freeway

Ahead of NBA Playoffs, this championship franchise has the most superstitious fan base in sports

In a sworn declaration, G.F. says he believes the vaccine could irreparably harm his son, who has already contracted and recovered from the coronavirus and may have strong natural immunity.

"Further, I worry that vaccinating him could prove even more dangerous now that he has had COVID-19,'' G.F. says. "Among other things, I fear that the vaccination could overexcite his immune system and antibodies.''

Having weighed those risks against what he believes to be a "statistically minuscule risk'' that his son will contract the coronavirus again, G.F. says he "vehemently objects to LAUSD's attempt to force his (son's) vaccination.''

D.F. has received all other required childhood immunizations, according to his father.

In their court papers, LAUSD lawyers maintain that the court relief sought by G.F. and his son "fails on every conceivable level'' and should have been denied.

The relief sought by G.F. "asks this court to ignore the life- threatening risks presented by COVID-19 and the corresponding threat it poses to public education...''  the LAUSD attorneys argued in their court papers.

Contact Us